Fired FBI official Andrew McCabe wins retirement benefits and back pay in settlement

Oct 14, 2021
Originally published on October 15, 2021 10:11 am

Updated October 14, 2021 at 6:40 PM ET

The Justice Department has agreed to restore full law enforcement benefits and provide some attorney fees for former FBI Deputy Director Andrew McCabe, who was fired by the Trump administration only hours before his retirement three years ago.

The settlement will resolve a civil lawsuit filed by McCabe, who argued that his ouster was the result of a "years-long public vendetta" driven by the former president.

The Justice Department demoted and then dismissed him on the eve of his 50th birthday in March 2018, when his FBI annuity would have vested.

"I think the message that you get loud and clear from the terms of the settlement is that this never should have happened," McCabe said. "It feels like complete vindication, because that's what it is."

It feels like complete vindication, because that's what it is. - Andrew McCabe

The agreement follows a scathing online campaign by the former president to tarnish McCabe, who spent 21 years in service at the bureau.

A day after the dismissal, Trump tweeted that it represented "a great day for the hard working men and women of the FBI - A great day for democracy." Earlier, Trump had pushed the bureau to "clean house" and urged authorities to take action against McCabe before his planned retirement.

In his lawsuit, McCabe argued the firing violated his First Amendment rights by punishing him for his "perceived affiliation" with the Democratic Party and violated his Fifth Amendment due process rights by leaving him with little time to review evidence against him and prepare a defense in early 2018.

One of McCabe's attorneys at the time said a senior Justice Department official told him the department was making things up as it went along. Correspondence among the FBI, the Justice Department and the inspector general obtained through the Freedom of Information Act and other means suggested a race to get rid of McCabe under pressure from the White House.

The settlement talks intensified only after U.S. District Judge Randy Moss gave McCabe's lawyers a green light to seek documents and testimony from former and current officials involved in the firing, including then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions, then-Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein and FBI Director Christopher Wray.

Trump had accused McCabe of conflicts of interest because McCabe's wife, Jill McCabe, ran without success for a seat in the Virginia Senate and accepted contributions from Democratic Party stalwart and then-Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe, a longtime ally of Bill and Hillary Clinton. Andrew McCabe countered that he had run the arrangement past FBI lawyers and ethics officials.

Justice Department Inspector General Michael Horowitz later examined McCabe's conduct as part of a broader review of FBI activities in the election year of 2016. Horowitz concluded that McCabe "lacked candor" when he spoke with investigators about disclosures he authorized to The Wall Street Journal during the heated presidential race. Prosecutors brought the matter to a federal grand jury in Washington, D.C., but McCabe was never charged with criminal wrongdoing.

McCabe said the inspector general report was used by senior Justice Department officials as a "pretext" to dismiss him. McCabe opened investigations into Trump after the then-president fired then-FBI Director James Comey in the spring of 2017.

"The thing that concerns me going forward is firing me 26 hours before my retirement sends an unbelievably chilling message to the rest of the men and women of the FBI," McCabe told NPR's Morning Edition two years ago. "It sends a message that if you stand up for what you think is right, and you do the right thing, and you honor your obligations to this organization and the Constitution, that you too could be personally targeted and lose those things that you've been building towards your whole career."

The Justice Department did not admit wrongdoing or apologize to McCabe in the court filing late Thursday, but one part of the document says, "the Parties agree that Executive Branch officials outside the Department of Justice and its components should not comment publicly on ongoing career civil service employee disciplinary matters ... so as not to create any appearance of improper political influence."

The settlement follows mediation between McCabe and the Justice Department this summer. The deal will restore McCabe's full retirement package, purge his personnel file, allow for the return of his FBI badge and cover fees for his attorneys at the Arnold & Porter law firm.

His attorney, Murad Hussain, said, "What happened to Andrew was a travesty, not just for him and his family, but the rule of law."

Hussain said they filed a lawsuit in part "to take a stand for the rights of all civil servants, and that's exactly what this settlement does."

Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.

A MARTINEZ, HOST:

The FBI official who was fired after a brutal campaign of insults from former President Donald Trump is settling his lawsuit with the Justice Department. Andrew McCabe will be allowed to collect his full federal retirement benefits under the terms of the deal. He spoke with NPR justice correspondent Carrie Johnson about his case this week.

CARRIE JOHNSON, BYLINE: Andy McCabe says there's a simple reason why he sued the government he served for 21 years.

ANDREW MCCABE: I didn't file it to get rich. I didn't file it to take down the Justice Department. I filed it to recover the benefits that had been unfairly and improperly taken from me and my family. And I filed it to try to restore my reputation.

JOHNSON: The Justice Department fired McCabe from his job at the FBI in 2018, only hours before his law enforcement pension would have vested. Justice leaders cited what they called his lack of candor about a media leak investigation. Former President Trump tweeted, it was a good day for the men and women at the bureau. But McCabe argued he was let go because of undue political pressure and without being given due process. Now, three years later, the Biden Justice Department has agreed to reverse the dismissal, restore McCabe's pension and health care and pay some attorney's fees.

MCCABE: It feels like complete vindication because that's what it is.

JOHNSON: I asked what the settlement means to him.

MCCABE: I think the message that you get loud and clear from the terms of the settlement is that this should never have happened.

JOHNSON: Settlement talks intensified last summer after a judge gave McCabe the green light for documents and testimony from current and former justice officials involved in his firing. The country's civil servants are still recovering from drama during the Trump administration, when the president fired FBI Director Jim Comey and eventually pushed out the deputy director, McCabe. Trump lambasted McCabe because his wife ran for the state Senate in Virginia and accepted a contribution from then-Governor Terry McAuliffe, an ally of the Clintons. Now that Trump is out of office and McCabe has settled with new leaders at the Justice Department, McCabe says he's hopeful that signals a return to normalcy.

MCCABE: I'm hoping that men and women in the FBI and, more broadly, people in the civil service see this as a restoration of what we all believe in from the beginning - that people should be treated fairly, that they should be treated properly under the law and according to the processes that protect us all.

JOHNSON: McCabe says the last few years have been hard, especially for his parents and his kids. He's been teaching national security law and working as a TV analyst for CNN. McCabe says he's not sure what the future holds, but he's glad he stood up for himself against the DOJ and the White House.

Carrie Johnson, NPR News, Washington.

(SOUNDBITE OF CFCF'S "RAINING PATTERNS") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.